Baking Project (TWD): Onion Bialys

IMG_0413My first thought when I saw the recipe assignment for this week: What the ** is a bialys? Luckily, shortly thereafter I was watching an episode of the Sopranos and it just so happened Tony was eating one and made his underlings scrape out his onions because recent health issues. Ok. So it’s some sort of bread-thing. The picture of it in the cookbook makes it look like a cross between a bagel and a croissant. Or maybe that’s what I was hoping it would be. It was not.

IMG_0406To make a bialy, much like how you’d make any bread product, you foam up some yeast, stir in flour, let it rise, stir in more flour, let it rise, shape and bake. There really isn’t too much fancy going on here. In addition to the flour, there a little salt and sugar (for the yeast to munch on), but nothing crazy. It is shaped a little differently than most bread – with a mashed in depression that’s filled with sauteed onions. And it is baked a little differently – with iced cold water dumped in the oven to get some steam moving. But really, this is just bread.  Not even a little egg-wash on top to make them looked all glazed and pretty. Then again, maybe mine are a little undercooked?IMG_0407 IMG_0409So one thing I noticed in baking my bialys, was that my depressions did not stay depressions for very long. I mushed the center down with my finger and stabbed at it with a fork (presumably to vent it so it wouldn’t puff up), but every single one of them erupted their onions, giving them the look of, well, onion-topped kaiser rolls. There seem to be very little glamour to these things. And maybe there isn’t supposed to be.IMG_0408  IMG_0410

I’m not trying to say they weren’t good. They were as good as any loaf of freshly braked bread would be, but I guess I expected a little more? Perhaps I need to work on managing my expectations when it comes to baked items. My husband said they were good but was very confused about the blob of onions on the middle. He would preferred a more even distribution do that you didn’t get all the onions in one bite. I guess that’s understandable. Maybe you just have to be from NY/NJ (or Poland) to fully appreciate all that is a bialy.IMG_0411

I guess I didn’t really see what all the fuss is about. Next!

Check out the other TWD Bakers at Tuesdays With Dorie

About these ads


  1. I agree with you that it looks like a kaiser bun with some onions on top of it. Maybe next time you can fill the dough with those onions? Or make a really deep depression so that the dough will puff up around the onions? I don’t know but they look tasty enough ;-)

    1. Hah! That’s the sad part – there WAS a depression. But my depression puffed up while baking and spewed out the onions. Not sure what went wrong there. Oh well. You win some, you lose some!

  2. I had to keep pressing the center of my bialys down too. I did like these, but am interested in making them again but trying something different for the filling.

  3. I enjoyed these, though I too would have preferred the onion filling spread out more over the whole roll. The next day we sliced and toasted them. The half with no onions, tasted pretty much like white bread, so the hubby said.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s